Supplement for the Article:

Boolean network inference from time series data incorporating prior biological knowledge

Saad Haider, Ranadip Pal BMC Genomics 2012, 13(Suppl 6):S9 (26 October 2012)

Comparison with Synthetic Networks

Comparison with REVEAL (Liang et al.) and MDL (Zhao et al.)

 

Synthetic Network Comparison

Table Caption   (as word doc)                                          Table as XLS

Data_To_Generate_BN1 BN1 Diagram BN2_1path Diagram BN2_2path Diagram BN2_3path Diagram R_max_1path R_max_2path R_max_3path R_mean_1path_4transitions R_mean_2path_4transitions R_mean_3path_4transitions R_mean_1path_5transitions R_mean_2path_5transitions R_mean_3path_5transitions
bn001.txt BN1_001.jpg BN2_1path_001.jpg BN2_2path_001.jpg BN2_3path_001.jpg 0.44394 0.78788 1 0.28349 0.5907 0.66221 0.36736                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn002.txt BN1_002.jpg BN2_1path_002.jpg BN2_2path_002.jpg BN2_3path_002.jpg 0.29115 0.87757 1 0.16349 0.50843 0.60393 0.26166                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn003.txt BN1_003.jpg BN2_1path_003.jpg BN2_2path_003.jpg BN2_3path_003.jpg 0.26825 0.87143 1 0.12968 0.44803 0.62231 0.18576 0.60754 0.70961
bn004.txt BN1_004.jpg BN2_1path_004.jpg BN2_2path_004.jpg BN2_3path_004.jpg 0.29845 0.72121 0.82815 0.12288 0.4268 0.52283 0.21256                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn005.txt BN1_005.jpg BN2_1path_005.jpg BN2_2path_005.jpg BN2_3path_005.jpg 0.43552 1 1 0.17403 0.61807 0.58723 0.29192                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn006.txt BN1_006.jpg BN2_1path_006.jpg BN2_2path_006.jpg BN2_3path_006.jpg 0.24008 0.63987 0.79019 0.14043 0.34367 0.4728 0.19096                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn007.txt BN1_007.jpg BN2_1path_007.jpg BN2_2path_007.jpg BN2_3path_007.jpg 0.31959 0.87371 1 0.16716 0.48927 0.52189 0.23342                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn008.txt BN1_008.jpg BN2_1path_008.jpg BN2_2path_008.jpg BN2_3path_008.jpg 0.23146 0.58408 0.73018 0.12166 0.27219 0.35811 0.16952                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn009.txt BN1_009.jpg BN2_1path_009.jpg BN2_2path_009.jpg BN2_3path_009.jpg 0.24947 0.63506 0.85275 0.16334 0.41247 0.53523 0.1964                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn010.txt BN1_010.jpg BN2_1path_010.jpg BN2_2path_010.jpg BN2_3path_010.jpg 0.28083 0.59488 0.85769 0.16533                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.19984                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn011.txt BN1_011.jpg BN2_1path_011.jpg BN2_2path_011.jpg BN2_3path_011.jpg 0.30263 0.70943 1 0.1895 0.48926 0.64692 0.30263                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn012.txt BN1_012.jpg BN2_1path_012.jpg BN2_2path_012.jpg BN2_3path_012.jpg 0.42017 0.62465 0.79832 0.2644                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.42017                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn013.txt BN1_013.jpg BN2_1path_013.jpg BN2_2path_013.jpg BN2_3path_013.jpg 0.3641 0.83333 1 0.27252                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.32412                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn014.txt BN1_014.jpg BN2_1path_014.jpg BN2_2path_014.jpg BN2_3path_014.jpg 0.38585 0.75566 0.92453 0.21279 0.45799 0.5821 0.30274                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn015.txt BN1_015.jpg BN2_1path_015.jpg BN2_2path_015.jpg BN2_3path_015.jpg 0.36894 0.88656 0.96366 0.19815 0.63892 0.70115 0.22397 0.78025 0.7638
bn016.txt BN1_016.jpg BN2_1path_016.jpg BN2_2path_016.jpg BN2_3path_016.jpg 0.32759 0.6772 0.79598 0.16383 0.41222 0.4989 0.23398 0.52768 0.63953
bn017.txt BN1_017.jpg BN2_1path_017.jpg BN2_2path_017.jpg BN2_3path_017.jpg 0.30503 0.57842 0.78163 0.21192 0.43516 0.49286 0.2721                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn018.txt BN1_018.jpg BN2_1path_018.jpg BN2_2path_018.jpg BN2_3path_018.jpg 0.41317 0.63585 0.92577 0.25593                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.32969                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn019.txt BN1_019.jpg BN2_1path_019.jpg BN2_2path_019.jpg BN2_3path_019.jpg 0.29798 0.69545 1 0.12846 0.37863 0.4836 0.23369                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn020.txt BN1_020.jpg BN2_1path_020.jpg BN2_2path_020.jpg BN2_3path_020.jpg 0.26195 0.70772 1 0.14126 0.43435 0.65215 0.2261                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn021.txt BN1_021.jpg BN2_1path_021.jpg BN2_2path_021.jpg BN2_3path_021.jpg 0.18987 0.45113 0.88186 0.11229 0.23947 0.35591 0.13145 0.31382 0.4391
bn022.txt BN1_022.jpg BN2_1path_022.jpg BN2_2path_022.jpg BN2_3path_022.jpg 0.16114 0.5368 1 0.089421 0.23819 0.41338 0.10671 0.30083 0.49252
bn023.txt BN1_023.jpg BN2_1path_023.jpg BN2_2path_023.jpg BN2_3path_023.jpg 0.15581 0.57315 1 0.090468 0.24865 0.42435 0.10104 0.30401 0.539
bn024.txt BN1_024.jpg BN2_1path_024.jpg BN2_2path_024.jpg BN2_3path_024.jpg 0.15734 0.54869 1 0.079826 0.21652 0.42876 0.10613 0.31592 0.56063
bn025.txt BN1_025.jpg BN2_1path_025.jpg BN2_2path_025.jpg BN2_3path_025.jpg 0.30049 0.94847 1 0.11134 0.30006 0.40014 0.20727                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn026.txt BN1_026.jpg BN2_1path_026.jpg BN2_2path_026.jpg BN2_3path_026.jpg 0.17533 0.51186 0.82719 0.086689 0.2227 0.35266 0.09797 0.25669 0.38266
bn027.txt BN1_027.jpg BN2_1path_027.jpg BN2_2path_027.jpg BN2_3path_027.jpg 0.18072 0.52175 1 0.087248 0.25599 0.39933 0.10192 0.30414 0.46881
bn028.txt BN1_028.jpg BN2_1path_028.jpg BN2_2path_028.jpg BN2_3path_028.jpg 0.35076 0.57407 1 0.11002 0.2712 0.42907 0.1617                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn029.txt BN1_029.jpg BN2_1path_029.jpg BN2_2path_029.jpg BN2_3path_029.jpg 0.32554 0.7464 1 0.08644 0.24665 0.39496 0.10483 0.30283 0.46216
bn030.txt BN1_030.jpg BN2_1path_030.jpg BN2_2path_030.jpg BN2_3path_030.jpg 0.17976 0.71937 1 0.0898 0.25947 0.42195 0.10304 0.32276 0.50922
bn031.txt BN1_031.jpg BN2_1path_031.jpg BN2_2path_031.jpg BN2_3path_031.jpg 0.18241 0.64511 0.91376 0.095571 0.25383 0.38016 0.10172 0.27295 0.39165
bn032.txt BN1_032.jpg BN2_1path_032.jpg BN2_2path_032.jpg BN2_3path_032.jpg 0.24065 0.75242 1 0.087549 0.25717 0.40808 0.12592 0.40771 0.5569
bn033.txt BN1_033.jpg BN2_1path_033.jpg BN2_2path_033.jpg BN2_3path_033.jpg 0.18474 0.556 1 0.081961 0.22827 0.39162 0.11879 0.28639 0.43844
bn034.txt BN1_034.jpg BN2_1path_034.jpg BN2_2path_034.jpg BN2_3path_034.jpg 0.2003 0.8316 1 0.095368 0.28628 0.42925 0.14591 0.30806 0.47759
bn035.txt BN1_035.jpg BN2_1path_035.jpg BN2_2path_035.jpg BN2_3path_035.jpg 0.20992 0.51336 1 0.078492 0.24272 0.39863 0.09735 0.31511 0.48542
bn036.txt BN1_036.jpg BN2_1path_036.jpg BN2_2path_036.jpg BN2_3path_036.jpg 0.17898 0.60866 1 0.093401 0.27134 0.41761 0.11721 0.34639 0.55642
bn037.txt BN1_037.jpg BN2_1path_037.jpg BN2_2path_037.jpg BN2_3path_037.jpg 0.29947 1 1 0.078985 0.26167 0.42584 0.10231 0.30743 0.48125
bn038.txt BN1_038.jpg BN2_1path_038.jpg BN2_2path_038.jpg BN2_3path_038.jpg 0.27003 0.78709 1 0.10596 0.27777 0.44139 0.16517 0.42056 0.60323
bn039.txt BN1_039.jpg BN2_1path_039.jpg BN2_2path_039.jpg BN2_3path_039.jpg 0.15251 0.59489 1 0.082873 0.26812 0.43915 0.082058 0.31382 0.53885
bn040.txt BN1_040.jpg BN2_1path_040.jpg BN2_2path_040.jpg BN2_3path_040.jpg 0.23965 0.58592 1 0.089879 0.24026 0.42817 0.13106 0.35775 0.57231
bn041.txt BN1_041.jpg BN2_1path_041.jpg BN2_2path_041.jpg BN2_3path_041.jpg 0.41117 1 1 0.13431 0.38843 0.42956 0.13547 0.39102 0.43132
bn042.txt BN1_042.jpg BN2_1path_042.jpg BN2_2path_042.jpg BN2_3path_042.jpg 0.37256 0.83442 0.90584 0.17247 0.45772 0.53173 0.27501 0.61857 0.68549
bn043.txt BN1_043.jpg BN2_1path_043.jpg BN2_2path_043.jpg BN2_3path_043.jpg 0.27911 0.68064 0.80388 0.1344 0.37091 0.42675 0.1344 0.37091 0.42675
bn044.txt BN1_044.jpg BN2_1path_044.jpg BN2_2path_044.jpg BN2_3path_044.jpg 0.473 1 1 0.14526 0.43713 0.47374 0.14997 0.44984 0.48702
bn045.txt BN1_045.jpg BN2_1path_045.jpg BN2_2path_045.jpg BN2_3path_045.jpg 0.29555 0.8543 1 0.12941 0.363 0.51283 0.1599 0.42853 0.59266
bn046.txt BN1_046.jpg BN2_1path_046.jpg BN2_2path_046.jpg BN2_3path_046.jpg 0.4008 0.89681 0.94863 0.16089 0.43899 0.58675 0.21013 0.52961 0.66428
bn047.txt BN1_047.jpg BN2_1path_047.jpg BN2_2path_047.jpg BN2_3path_047.jpg 0.36341 0.82456 0.97619 0.1389 0.37916 0.42591 0.19531 0.5335 0.5807
bn048.txt BN1_048.jpg BN2_1path_048.jpg BN2_2path_048.jpg BN2_3path_048.jpg 0.39158 1 1 0.14762 0.385 0.47109 0.17204 0.44654 0.56638
bn049.txt BN1_049.jpg BN2_1path_049.jpg BN2_2path_049.jpg BN2_3path_049.jpg 0.53332 0.81367 1 0.14779 0.41934 0.49962 0.17382 0.46705 0.50464
bn050.txt BN1_050.jpg BN2_1path_050.jpg BN2_2path_050.jpg BN2_3path_050.jpg 0.28052 0.96753 0.96753 0.13199 0.36489 0.48063 0.1524 0.40557 0.53901
bn051.txt BN1_051.jpg BN2_1path_051.jpg BN2_2path_051.jpg BN2_3path_051.jpg 0.27273 0.92984 0.92984 0.18102 0.53167 0.55046 0.24061 0.65548 0.72248
bn052.txt BN1_052.jpg BN2_1path_052.jpg BN2_2path_052.jpg BN2_3path_052.jpg 0.31294 0.84884 1 0.11972 0.36472 0.42747 0.12547 0.37936 0.44132
bn053.txt BN1_053.jpg BN2_1path_053.jpg BN2_2path_053.jpg BN2_3path_053.jpg 0.36062 0.8694 0.94932 0.16882 0.41366 0.46629 0.24589 0.60215 0.60645
bn054.txt BN1_054.jpg BN2_1path_054.jpg BN2_2path_054.jpg BN2_3path_054.jpg 0.35965 0.78205 1 0.14766 0.37854 0.47313 0.19767 0.49325 0.61839
bn055.txt BN1_055.jpg BN2_1path_055.jpg BN2_2path_055.jpg BN2_3path_055.jpg 0.33943 0.75374 0.84193 0.15978 0.39679 0.47427 0.2417 0.55891 0.6154
bn056.txt BN1_056.jpg BN2_1path_056.jpg BN2_2path_056.jpg BN2_3path_056.jpg 0.31812 0.8603 0.87275 0.15581 0.38322 0.4806 0.18254 0.49209 0.58602
bn057.txt BN1_057.jpg BN2_1path_057.jpg BN2_2path_057.jpg BN2_3path_057.jpg 0.39994 1 1 0.15354 0.43396 0.49962 0.22561 0.66557 0.66058
bn058.txt BN1_058.jpg BN2_1path_058.jpg BN2_2path_058.jpg BN2_3path_058.jpg 0.36314 0.92141 0.92141 0.18114 0.44881 0.50617 0.22886 0.57261 0.57414
bn059.txt BN1_059.jpg BN2_1path_059.jpg BN2_2path_059.jpg BN2_3path_059.jpg 0.37044 1 1 0.15018 0.37162 0.54291 0.18015 0.45906 0.66419
bn060.txt BN1_060.jpg BN2_1path_060.jpg BN2_2path_060.jpg BN2_3path_060.jpg 0.4251 0.91956 0.91956 0.15998 0.44924 0.5589 0.21768 0.61364 0.71353
bn061.txt BN1_061.jpg BN2_1path_061.jpg BN2_2path_061.jpg                               N/A 0.54859 0.91869                NaN 0.14542 0.46655                                             NaN 0.15496 0.48557                                             NaN
bn062.txt BN1_062.jpg BN2_1path_062.jpg BN2_2path_062.jpg                               N/A 0.1229 1                NaN 0.050594 0.56941                                             NaN 0.055479 0.73891                                             NaN
bn063.txt BN1_063.jpg BN2_1path_063.jpg BN2_2path_063.jpg                               N/A 0.33266 1                NaN 0.12871 0.5203                                             NaN 0.15053                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn064.txt BN1_064.jpg BN2_1path_064.jpg BN2_2path_064.jpg                               N/A 0.44196 1                NaN 0.099175                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.10532                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn065.txt BN1_065.jpg BN2_1path_065.jpg BN2_2path_065.jpg                               N/A 0.34014 0.90422                NaN 0.14292                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.14626                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn066.txt BN1_066.jpg BN2_1path_066.jpg BN2_2path_066.jpg                               N/A 0.63872 1                NaN 0.14717 0.35324                                             NaN 0.17405                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn067.txt BN1_067.jpg BN2_1path_067.jpg BN2_2path_067.jpg                               N/A 0.70552 1                NaN 0.082458 0.48061                                             NaN 0.09565 0.53541                                             NaN
bn068.txt BN1_068.jpg BN2_1path_068.jpg BN2_2path_068.jpg                               N/A 0.087741 1                NaN 0.052715 0.47599                                             NaN 0.057623 0.59954                                             NaN
bn069.txt BN1_069.jpg BN2_1path_069.jpg BN2_2path_069.jpg                               N/A 0.36343 1                NaN 0.10863                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.12228                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn070.txt BN1_070.jpg BN2_1path_070.jpg BN2_2path_070.jpg                               N/A 0.80054 1                NaN 0.15038 0.47608                                             NaN 0.18158 0.57564                                             NaN
bn071.txt BN1_071.jpg BN2_1path_071.jpg BN2_2path_071.jpg                               N/A 0.1227 1                NaN 0.051841 0.51971                                             NaN 0.058469 0.64739                                             NaN
bn072.txt BN1_072.jpg BN2_1path_072.jpg BN2_2path_072.jpg                               N/A 0.36185 1                NaN 0.13392 0.57214                                             NaN 0.16493 0.62982                                             NaN
bn073.txt BN1_073.jpg BN2_1path_073.jpg BN2_2path_073.jpg                               N/A 0.29702 0.75999                NaN 0.09673 0.58277                                             NaN 0.10238                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn074.txt BN1_074.jpg BN2_1path_074.jpg BN2_2path_074.jpg                               N/A 0.32793 1                NaN 0.12337 0.58514                                             NaN 0.13988 0.62477                                             NaN
bn075.txt BN1_075.jpg BN2_1path_075.jpg BN2_2path_075.jpg                               N/A 0.12146 1                NaN 0.049067 0.51533                                             NaN 0.053172 0.55202                                             NaN
bn076.txt BN1_076.jpg BN2_1path_076.jpg BN2_2path_076.jpg                               N/A 0.43649 1                NaN 0.12479 0.56126                                             NaN 0.1361 0.6119                                             NaN
bn077.txt BN1_077.jpg BN2_1path_077.jpg BN2_2path_077.jpg                               N/A 0.53538 1                NaN 0.12013 0.4931                                             NaN 0.14 0.66267                                             NaN
bn078.txt BN1_078.jpg BN2_1path_078.jpg BN2_2path_078.jpg                               N/A 0.3076 1                NaN 0.13312 0.41786                                             NaN 0.14212                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn079.txt BN1_079.jpg BN2_1path_079.jpg BN2_2path_079.jpg                               N/A 0.81586 1                NaN 0.15362 0.49473                                             NaN 0.17249 0.53377                                             NaN
bn080.txt BN1_080.jpg BN2_1path_080.jpg BN2_2path_080.jpg                               N/A 0.73154 0.82728                NaN 0.13574 0.42617                                             NaN 0.15083 0.49162                                             NaN
bn081.txt BN1_081.jpg BN2_1path_081.jpg BN2_2path_081.jpg                               N/A 0.30303 0.84394                NaN 0.091273 0.44199                                             NaN 0.11322 0.57372                                             NaN
bn082.txt BN1_082.jpg BN2_1path_082.jpg BN2_2path_082.jpg                               N/A 0.35011 0.87813                NaN 0.13668 0.49002                                             NaN 0.18152 0.62071                                             NaN
bn083.txt BN1_083.jpg BN2_1path_083.jpg BN2_2path_083.jpg                               N/A 0.37086 0.86341                NaN 0.12129 0.50773                                             NaN 0.23692                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn084.txt BN1_084.jpg BN2_1path_084.jpg BN2_2path_084.jpg                               N/A 0.22789 0.69728                NaN 0.092874 0.45509                                             NaN 0.10535 0.5082                                             NaN
bn085.txt BN1_085.jpg BN2_1path_085.jpg BN2_2path_085.jpg                               N/A 0.50501 1                NaN 0.11922 0.50011                                             NaN 0.14905 0.60253                                             NaN
bn086.txt BN1_086.jpg BN2_1path_086.jpg BN2_2path_086.jpg                               N/A 0.50915 1                NaN 0.18661 0.52633                                             NaN 0.22605 0.64922                                             NaN
bn087.txt BN1_087.jpg BN2_1path_087.jpg BN2_2path_087.jpg                               N/A 0.45799 0.91782                NaN 0.15108 0.49264                                             NaN 0.19992 0.57704                                             NaN
bn088.txt BN1_088.jpg BN2_1path_088.jpg BN2_2path_088.jpg                               N/A 0.1619 0.7127                NaN 0.088502 0.41702                                             NaN 0.044444                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn089.txt BN1_089.jpg BN2_1path_089.jpg BN2_2path_089.jpg                               N/A 0.32622 0.76436                NaN 0.11113 0.45802                                             NaN 0.27237                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn090.txt BN1_090.jpg BN2_1path_090.jpg BN2_2path_090.jpg                               N/A 0.35011 0.89933                NaN 0.12928 0.56815                                             NaN 0.16409 0.69332                                             NaN
bn091.txt BN1_091.jpg BN2_1path_091.jpg BN2_2path_091.jpg                               N/A 0.22686 0.56011                NaN 0.092379 0.33741                                             NaN 0.11961 0.39317                                             NaN
bn092.txt BN1_092.jpg BN2_1path_092.jpg BN2_2path_092.jpg                               N/A 0.42463 0.86837                NaN 0.13306 0.58827                                             NaN 0.17438 0.73558                                             NaN
bn093.txt BN1_093.jpg BN2_1path_093.jpg BN2_2path_093.jpg                               N/A 0.79234 0.94225                NaN 0.21714 0.55358                                             NaN 0.30724 0.64291                                             NaN
bn094.txt BN1_094.jpg BN2_1path_094.jpg BN2_2path_094.jpg                               N/A 0.34797 1                NaN 0.11056 0.42775                                             NaN 0.14693 0.57401                                             NaN
bn095.txt BN1_095.jpg BN2_1path_095.jpg BN2_2path_095.jpg                               N/A 0.27471 0.85029                NaN 0.10642 0.46902                                             NaN 0.13405 0.55055                                             NaN
bn096.txt BN1_096.jpg BN2_1path_096.jpg BN2_2path_096.jpg                               N/A 0.16542 0.72455                NaN 0.087013 0.47951                                             NaN 0.085891                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn097.txt BN1_097.jpg BN2_1path_097.jpg BN2_2path_097.jpg                               N/A 0.16935 0.8629                NaN 0.086864 0.49334                                             NaN 0.085377 0.57753                                             NaN
bn098.txt BN1_098.jpg BN2_1path_098.jpg BN2_2path_098.jpg                               N/A 0.27629 0.81223                NaN 0.12038 0.49479                                             NaN 0.1538 0.62802                                             NaN
bn099.txt BN1_099.jpg BN2_1path_099.jpg BN2_2path_099.jpg                               N/A 0.36891 0.8                NaN 0.11715 0.4013                                             NaN 0.16198 0.50543                                             NaN
bn100.txt BN1_100.jpg BN2_1path_100.jpg BN2_2path_100.jpg                               N/A 0.22471 0.84324                NaN 0.093405 0.49069                                             NaN 0.10234 0.5571                                             NaN
bn101.txt BN1_101.jpg BN2_1path_101.jpg BN2_2path_101.jpg BN2_3path_101.jpg 0.52756 1 1 0.1841 0.35512 0.38494 0.2454                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn102.txt BN1_102.jpg BN2_1path_102.jpg BN2_2path_102.jpg BN2_3path_102.jpg 0.46293 1 1 0.17276                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.19209                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn103.txt BN1_103.jpg BN2_1path_103.jpg BN2_2path_103.jpg BN2_3path_103.jpg 0.29427 0.6751 1 0.155 0.33073 0.5074 0.18699 0.46146 0.56231
bn104.txt BN1_104.jpg BN2_1path_104.jpg BN2_2path_104.jpg BN2_3path_104.jpg 0.33218 0.78918 1 0.15274 0.34919 0.48917 0.20532 0.48754 0.6941
bn105.txt BN1_105.jpg BN2_1path_105.jpg BN2_2path_105.jpg BN2_3path_105.jpg 0.48971 1 1 0.23259 0.4494 0.58448 0.2445 0.47728 0.6223
bn106.txt BN1_106.jpg BN2_1path_106.jpg BN2_2path_106.jpg BN2_3path_106.jpg 0.49389 1 1 0.18235 0.47153 0.56713 0.19202 0.5092 0.57548
bn107.txt BN1_107.jpg BN2_1path_107.jpg BN2_2path_107.jpg BN2_3path_107.jpg 0.39735 0.77065 1 0.11022 0.37098 0.46578 0.1551 0.45158 0.58578
bn108.txt BN1_108.jpg BN2_1path_108.jpg BN2_2path_108.jpg BN2_3path_108.jpg 0.75676 1 1 0.15401 0.36364 0.51319 0.16705 0.38893 0.53455
bn109.txt BN1_109.jpg BN2_1path_109.jpg BN2_2path_109.jpg BN2_3path_109.jpg 0.38324 0.77794 1 0.19196                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.22118                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn110.txt BN1_110.jpg BN2_1path_110.jpg BN2_2path_110.jpg BN2_3path_110.jpg 0.67215 1 1 0.20042 0.31672 0.39309 0.24196 0.36969 0.45338
bn111.txt BN1_111.jpg BN2_1path_111.jpg BN2_2path_111.jpg BN2_3path_111.jpg 0.33755 0.81453 1 0.15811 0.35246 0.60753 0.19676 0.46307 0.75006
bn112.txt BN1_112.jpg BN2_1path_112.jpg BN2_2path_112.jpg BN2_3path_112.jpg 0.34612 0.61287 0.83907 0.21322 0.32396 0.42507 0.24709 0.42734 0.45895
bn113.txt BN1_113.jpg BN2_1path_113.jpg BN2_2path_113.jpg BN2_3path_113.jpg 0.42679 0.83981 0.83981 0.096573                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.10718                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn114.txt BN1_114.jpg BN2_1path_114.jpg BN2_2path_114.jpg BN2_3path_114.jpg 0.62277 1 1 0.19014 0.3613 0.45474 0.26789 0.49815 0.59501
bn115.txt BN1_115.jpg BN2_1path_115.jpg BN2_2path_115.jpg BN2_3path_115.jpg 0.35756 0.92194 1 0.11776 0.34198 0.49731 0.14028 0.51801 0.72602
bn116.txt BN1_116.jpg BN2_1path_116.jpg BN2_2path_116.jpg                               N/A 0.53516 1                NaN 0.2234 0.42751                                             NaN 0.27176 0.5224                                             NaN
bn117.txt BN1_117.jpg BN2_1path_117.jpg BN2_2path_117.jpg BN2_3path_117.jpg 0.44033 1 1 0.17247 0.3718 0.45084 0.18862 0.49249 0.54503
bn118.txt BN1_118.jpg BN2_1path_118.jpg BN2_2path_118.jpg BN2_3path_118.jpg 0.38771 0.82299 1 0.15162 0.41046 0.4617 0.15996 0.42738 0.47873
bn119.txt BN1_119.jpg BN2_1path_119.jpg BN2_2path_119.jpg BN2_3path_119.jpg 0.85968 1 1 0.398                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.4185                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn120.txt BN1_120.jpg BN2_1path_120.jpg BN2_2path_120.jpg BN2_3path_120.jpg 0.33858 1 1 0.12798 0.31051 0.35777 0.14513 0.36458 0.43301
bn121.txt BN1_121.jpg BN2_1path_121.jpg BN2_2path_121.jpg BN2_3path_121.jpg 0.35417 0.82813 1 0.13901 0.51068 0.70262 0.19283 0.65205 0.76283
bn122.txt BN1_122.jpg BN2_1path_122.jpg BN2_2path_122.jpg BN2_3path_122.jpg 0.21372 0.77802 0.86458 0.10877 0.45968 0.54063 0.1396 0.56244 0.63969
bn123.txt BN1_123.jpg BN2_1path_123.jpg BN2_2path_123.jpg BN2_3path_123.jpg 0.27754 0.83261 0.83261 0.12103                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.13284                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn124.txt BN1_124.jpg BN2_1path_124.jpg BN2_2path_124.jpg BN2_3path_124.jpg 0.21643 0.79682 0.85866 0.11884                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.13883                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn125.txt BN1_125.jpg BN2_1path_125.jpg BN2_2path_125.jpg BN2_3path_125.jpg 0.14147 0.56742 0.56742 0.097648                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.10239                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn126.txt BN1_126.jpg BN2_1path_126.jpg BN2_2path_126.jpg BN2_3path_126.jpg 0.40556 0.92323 1 0.12761 0.58611 0.66499 0.17942                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn127.txt BN1_127.jpg BN2_1path_127.jpg BN2_2path_127.jpg BN2_3path_127.jpg 0.44538 0.75204 0.86129 0.20886 0.46071 0.53419 0.27918 0.5682 0.6102
bn128.txt BN1_128.jpg BN2_1path_128.jpg BN2_2path_128.jpg BN2_3path_128.jpg 0.16048 0.81659 0.86026 0.093341 0.57816 0.63312                                            NaN                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn129.txt BN1_129.jpg BN2_1path_129.jpg BN2_2path_129.jpg BN2_3path_129.jpg 0.16004 0.80945 0.86772 0.10527                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.10734                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn130.txt BN1_130.jpg BN2_1path_130.jpg BN2_2path_130.jpg BN2_3path_130.jpg 0.12581 0.85622 1 0.086147 0.41664 0.51354 0.092535 0.47731 0.53941
bn131.txt BN1_131.jpg BN2_1path_131.jpg BN2_2path_131.jpg BN2_3path_131.jpg 0.53744 0.77538 0.77538 0.32117 0.57744 0.51071 0.43372                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn132.txt BN1_132.jpg BN2_1path_132.jpg BN2_2path_132.jpg BN2_3path_132.jpg 0.1405 0.80165 0.8168 0.10441                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.10698                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn133.txt BN1_133.jpg BN2_1path_133.jpg BN2_2path_133.jpg BN2_3path_133.jpg 0.14731 0.974 1 0.1166                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.1278                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn134.txt BN1_134.jpg BN2_1path_134.jpg BN2_2path_134.jpg BN2_3path_134.jpg 0.12412 0.97368 1 0.1067 0.38497 0.5605 0.11176 0.46942 0.82895
bn135.txt BN1_135.jpg BN2_1path_135.jpg BN2_2path_135.jpg BN2_3path_135.jpg 0.12842 0.70208 0.85104 0.082287 0.35841 0.46907 0.0885 0.53476 0.5834
bn136.txt BN1_136.jpg BN2_1path_136.jpg BN2_2path_136.jpg BN2_3path_136.jpg 0.12299 0.56015 0.56337 0.095261                                               NaN                                             NaN 0.097079                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn137.txt BN1_137.jpg BN2_1path_137.jpg BN2_2path_137.jpg BN2_3path_137.jpg 0.2981 0.82898 0.86461 0.1505 0.53064 0.68634                                            NaN                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn138.txt BN1_138.jpg BN2_1path_138.jpg BN2_2path_138.jpg BN2_3path_138.jpg 0.20903 0.96437 1 0.10232 0.50518 0.74581                                            NaN                                                NaN                                             NaN
bn139.txt BN1_139.jpg BN2_1path_139.jpg BN2_2path_139.jpg BN2_3path_139.jpg 0.24786 0.73077 0.86538 0.10471 0.53483 0.61698 0.11507 0.62489 0.67726
bn140.txt BN1_140.jpg BN2_1path_140.jpg BN2_2path_140.jpg BN2_3path_140.jpg 0.52856 1 1 0.19085 0.54611 0.67373 0.25883 0.63801 0.72221

 
Comparison with REVEAL (Liang et al.) and MDL (Zhao et al.)
Data_To_Generate_BN1 BN1 Diagram BN2_Haider et al. Diagram BN2 Zhao et al. Diagram BN2 REVEAL Liang et al. Diagram R Max Haider R Zhao R_REVEAL
bn001.txt BN1_001.jpg BN2_1path_001.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_001.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_001.jpg 0.44394 0.097 0
bn002.txt BN1_002.jpg BN2_1path_002.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_002.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_002.jpg 0.29115 0.0149 0
bn003.txt BN1_003.jpg BN2_1path_003.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_003.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_003.jpg 0.26825 0.0159 0.0099
bn004.txt BN1_004.jpg BN2_1path_004.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_004.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_004.jpg 0.29845 0.1266 0
bn005.txt BN1_005.jpg BN2_1path_005.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_005.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_005.jpg 0.43552 0.0275 0
bn006.txt BN1_006.jpg BN2_1path_006.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_006.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_006.jpg 0.24008 0.0762 0
bn007.txt BN1_007.jpg BN2_1path_007.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_007.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_007.jpg 0.31959 0.1684 0.0069
bn008.txt BN1_008.jpg BN2_1path_008.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_008.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_008.jpg 0.23146 0.0825 0.1151
bn009.txt BN1_009.jpg BN2_1path_009.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_009.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_009.jpg 0.24947 0.1589 0
bn010.txt BN1_010.jpg BN2_1path_010.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_010.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_010.jpg 0.28083 0.0754 0
bn011.txt BN1_011.jpg BN2_1path_011.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_011.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_011.jpg 0.30263 0.0587 0
bn012.txt BN1_012.jpg BN2_1path_012.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_012.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_012.jpg 0.42017 0.0266 0
bn013.txt BN1_013.jpg BN2_1path_013.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_013.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_013.jpg 0.3641 0.0141 0.0897
bn014.txt BN1_014.jpg BN2_1path_014.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_014.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_014.jpg 0.38585 0.0802 0
bn015.txt BN1_015.jpg BN2_1path_015.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_015.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_015.jpg 0.36894 0.0556 0
bn016.txt BN1_016.jpg BN2_1path_016.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_016.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_016.jpg 0.32759 0.023 0
bn017.txt BN1_017.jpg BN2_1path_017.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_017.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_017.jpg 0.30503 0.1101 0.0273
bn018.txt BN1_018.jpg BN2_1path_018.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_018.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_018.jpg 0.41317 0.0259 0.0063
bn019.txt BN1_019.jpg BN2_1path_019.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_019.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_019.jpg 0.29798 0.0121 0
bn020.txt BN1_020.jpg BN2_1path_020.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_020.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_020.jpg 0.26195 0.0331 0
bn021.txt BN1_021.jpg BN2_1path_021.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_021.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_021.jpg 0.18987 0.0285 0.0042
bn022.txt BN1_022.jpg BN2_1path_022.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_022.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_022.jpg 0.16114 0.071 0
bn023.txt BN1_023.jpg BN2_1path_023.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_023.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_023.jpg 0.15581 0.012 0.0035
bn024.txt BN1_024.jpg BN2_1path_024.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_024.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_024.jpg 0.15734 0.0203 0
bn025.txt BN1_025.jpg BN2_1path_025.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_zhao_025.jpg BN2_1path_comparison_reveal_025.jpg 0.30049 0.0797 0.0003